Written by

In this article


Carrier scorecard

What is a Carrier Scorecard?

A carrier scorecard is a performance measurement tool used by supply chain and logistics professionals to evaluate the effectiveness and reliability of their freight carriers. It provides a standardized way to assess carriers based on various performance metrics, helping organizations make informed decisions about their logistics partners. Carrier scorecards are essential for maintaining high standards of service and ensuring that supply chain operations run smoothly.

Common Carrier Scorecard Metrics

Carrier scorecards typically include a variety of metrics to evaluate different aspects of carrier performance. Common metrics include:

  • On-Time Delivery: Measures the percentage of shipments delivered on or before the scheduled delivery date.
  • Transit Time: Evaluates the average time taken for shipments to reach their destination.
  • Freight Damage: Tracks the incidence of damaged goods during transit.
  • Billing Accuracy: Assesses the accuracy and timeliness of freight invoices.
  • Customer Service: Rates the responsiveness and effectiveness of the carrier’s customer service.

Benefits of Carrier Scorecards

Carrier scorecards offer several benefits to supply chain and logistics operations:

  • Improved Performance: By regularly monitoring and evaluating carrier performance, companies can identify areas for improvement and work with carriers to enhance service quality.
  • Cost Management: Scorecards help identify inefficiencies and areas where costs can be reduced, such as through better route planning or improved carrier selection.
  • Enhanced Relationships: Maintaining transparent and objective evaluations fosters better relationships with carriers, encouraging collaboration and continuous improvement.
  • Data-Driven Decisions: Scorecards provide a data-driven basis for making strategic decisions about carrier contracts and logistics planning.

How to Create a Freight Carrier Scorecard

Creating an effective freight carrier scorecard involves several steps:

  1. Identify Key Metrics: Determine which performance metrics are most important for your operations. This should align with your overall supply chain goals and customer expectations.
  2. Set Benchmarks: Establish performance benchmarks for each metric based on industry standards, historical data, and business requirements.
  3. Collect Data: Implement systems to regularly collect and update performance data from your carriers. This could involve automated tracking systems (like Beacon), manual reporting, or a combination of both.
  4. Analyze and Review: Regularly analyze the collected data to assess carrier performance against benchmarks. Review findings with carriers to address any issues and identify opportunities for improvement.
  5. Report and Adjust: Create regular reports to share with relevant stakeholders. Use insights from the scorecard to make adjustments in carrier selection, contract negotiations, and operational strategies.